A study led by Penn Nursing’s Center for Health Outcomes and Policy Research (**CHOPR**) and the Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics found that patients treated at for-profit hospitals experienced higher mortality and readmission rates. Nurses working in these hospitals reported less safe staffing and substantially worse working conditions.
The research examined outcomes for over 1.17 million patients across 143 for-profit and 798 nonprofit hospitals in 10 states. Nurse staffing differences accounted for part of the observed lower quality in for-profit hospitals.
Compared to nonprofit hospitals, for-profit hospitals showed roughly 11 additional deaths per 1,000 medical admissions and 5 per 1,000 surgical admissions. Thirty-day readmissions were 2.04 percentage points higher for medical patients and 1.76 percentage points higher for surgical patients. Patients also rated for-profit hospitals lower, with worse nurse staffing accounting for lower overall hospital ratings.
Nurses in for-profit hospitals reported markedly worse staffing, with 71% stating their assigned patient workloads were not safe. Nurse burnout was significantly higher in for-profit hospitals, and nurses were less likely to recommend the hospitals. The study suggests investments in nursing and state policies establishing safe staffing requirements are important mechanisms to ensure patient safety, nurse retention, and quality of care.
The authors conclude that policies establishing minimum safe nurse staffing requirements and enhancing hospital ownership transparency could meaningfully improve patient, nurse, and hospital outcomes.