This research aimed to compare and rank four performance evaluation models utilized in gas refineries. The study employed a grounded theory approach, involving 20 professionals and HSE managers with relevant experience.
Methodology and Results
The normal score method was applied, utilizing the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) to determine weights and subsequently integrating them with the Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to an Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) process. The evaluation criteria included the capability to quantify qualitative data for environmental performance, facilitating implementation, structuring, and mapping a roadmap of organization maturity. The geometric mean of the evaluation criteria was estimated at 1.22, 0.90, 0.95, and 0.96, respectively. The normal weights for the criteria were estimated at 0.3039423, 0.2242449, 0.2347026, and 0.2371102, respectively.
Environmental Performance Evaluation (EPE) Prioritization
The prioritization of Environmental Performance Evaluation (EPE) models based on TOPSIS indicated that the model with a relative proximity of 99% was the preferred choice for gas refineries. The research sought to address critical environmental problems through rational development, emphasizing the importance of appropriate performance measurement systems within organizations. TOPSIS and AHP were key components of this analysis.