Obesity is a complex, chronic disease presenting a significant global health challenge. Traditionally, population-level screening has relied heavily on body mass index (BMI).
Current Obesity Definitions
However, BMI does not account for individual variations in factors such as muscle mass, fat distribution, or metabolic health. Utilizing weight-to-height ratios, even when supplemented with measurements like waist circumference or ratios, offers limited precision in individual diagnosis and comprehensive risk assessment. A more detailed approach is needed to capture the diversity of obesity and enable individualized patient care. This narrative review examines various obesity definitions, including the World Health Organization classification, the Edmonton Obesity Staging System (EOSS), the Lancet Commission framework, and the European Association for the Study of Obesity framework.
Expanding Diagnostic Scope
BMI remains valuable for population-level assessment and may be useful at the individual level when combined with additional measurements and adjusted cutoff values based on sex, age, and ethnicity. The EOSS expands assessment by incorporating metabolic, physical, psychological, and functional consequences, guiding treatment intensity based on disease severity. The Lancet Commission’s definitions of preclinical and clinical obesity broaden the diagnostic scope but raise concerns regarding the lack of standardized screening tools and potential diagnostic inconsistency. This may be particularly relevant for children and adolescents, where delayed intervention could increase long-term health risks. Weight-history classifications, incorporating maximum weight attained, provide an additional perspective, supporting realistic treatment goals, emphasizing the chronic nature of obesity, reducing stigma, and promoting long-term adherence. No single classification fully represents the biological and clinical heterogeneity of obesity. A combined approach integrating BMI with anthropometric, metabolic, functional, psychological, and weight-history information may improve diagnostic accuracy, risk stratification, and patient-centered obesity care.